Apps on TV: A UI Challenge

In recent days, an announcement from Google and a detailed Apple rumor from Engadget tell us that smartphone apps will soon be coming to our smart TVs. Superficially, this sounds like a cool idea, but the more I think about it the less I get it. And the reason is user interfaces.

Faithful readers know that I have railed for a long time against attempts to add a thin layer of gesture support to a mouse-and-keyboard interface and think that you have a touch device. This has been a fundamental flaw in Microsoft’s Tablet PC efforts, even with the much improved touch support in Windows 7. There will never be a good Windows tablet or slate until Microsoft fundamentally rethinks the interface and builds touch support deep into the UI, and the applications are rewritten for touch as well.

But the fact is that it doesn;t make any more sense to take what is fundamentally a touch-based UI, like the iPhone OS or Android, and expect it to work with a pointer device (its true that Android phones have a D-pad or track ball, but I don;t know anyone who uses them much.) Touch just isn’t going to work on a TV. Even a free-space pointing device, such as the Hillcrest Labs Loop, is not a great substitute for hands-on in an interface designed for touch. A conventional remote would be a nightmare.

In that context, it is just foolishness to say that all Android or iPhone apps will work on these new TV systems. A few might, but especially on the iPhone and iPad, touch runs deep into the soul of most apps. I have a prize for the first person who succeeds at Harbor Master played with a remote.

Advertisements

2 Responses to “Apps on TV: A UI Challenge”

  1. Rich Repplier Says:

    “Touch just isn’t going to work on a TV.” That seems right. Unless I’m missing something, a touch interface on a device that’s viewed from 10 ft. away makes no sense.

  2. Jim Gable Says:

    Steve,

    That is true. Even with an in-air pointer like the Loop pointer, you really need TV interfaces and applications that were properly designed — like Hillcrest has been working on for quite a while. 🙂

    Although it could be true that some touch apps are easier to re-write as TV apps, but that is very dependent on the situation.

    Jim

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: